You can’t purchase anything at Staples, Best Buy or Office Depot without being offered an extended warranty. As a consumer, I would never buy one, nor would any sane person. The fine print always makes it difficult to redeem the warranty, and of course, insurance of most kinds are a losing proposition.
But what is the most amazing thing is that brands allow their products to be positioned as faulty at the time of purchase. I was buying a monitor at a Staples for a trade show last week. It wasn’t a critical purchase, to the point that I considered using the monitor and just giving it to one of our staff instead of bringing it back to Seattle, so aside from my bias there was definitely no interest in buying an extended warranty. But the conversation went like this:
“I’ll take this 32 inch one”
SALESPERSON: “Ok, great. Would you like an extended warranty for only $23.99?”
“No, I’m good. Thanks though.:
SALESPERSON: “Are you sure? Those monitors have a habit of breaking down and this will save you a ton of trouble with that”
ME: “No, really, I’m good. I know you guys have incentives to sell warranties, but it’s just something I need for the short term”
SALESPERSON: “Look, I have to tell you, it’s not about my incentive. These models have been giving us a lot of trouble. You should really look at buying the warranty”
ME: “So you’re saying I’m buying a product from you that probably isn’t going to work?”
SALESPERSON: “I’m just saying you should buy the warranty”.
Do the retail experience “wizards” at these places not understand the utter lunacy of this strategy? Imagine landing the client of your dreams, and right after they sign your agreement, you produce another “insurance” doc for 10% of the price, because “lately we haven’t been performing very well”.
It’s pure lunacy: You get people to the point of purchase, where they are experiencing the highest level of dopamine in the purchase process: “I have my product and I am about to enjoy it” — and some guy tells you you’re making a big mistake for the sake of a $1 commission.
Here’s the point: When you get to the point of making a sale, let your customers enjoy it. Fear and uncertainty can drive demand for products — but don’t let that take away from your core business.